ABSTRACT
Intrinsic motivation is one of the eight favorable personal characteristics for science creativity (Romo 2008). However, intrinsic motivation can be negatively affected by introducing external constraints such as surveillance (Amabile 1998), proper of authoritarian and totalitarian regimes those that still persist today (Lewandosky et al., 2025).
More than fifty years ago, on September 11, 1973, Chile faced a coup that ended its long-standing democratic political system for 17 years till 1990 (Bautista et al., 2019. In the beginning, heated debates arose among academics from public and private universities, criticizing (Izquierdo 1975, Cordero et al., 1984) or relativizing this dictatorship (Eyzaguirre 1974, Litvak 1984). However, in modern times the legacies of that dictatorship have affected higher education through generations of students and educational policies for more than half a century (Bautista et al., 2023, 2024; González et al., 2024). Did this coup also had a negative impact on the country’s research productivity and scientometric impact in experimental Biomedical and Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Sciences?
To assess this question, I obtained scientometric data from the Web of Science (WoS) choosing two biomedical categories (the only two for the country at this time): General Internal Medicine (GIM) and Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (BMB), and three equal 17-year comparable periods (before, during and after the dictatorship): 1956-1972 (democracy), 1973-1990 (the length of dictatorship) and 1991-2007 (return to the previous democracy).
Data in Table 1 shows that citations/publications were sharply reduced during Chile’s dictatorship period. In fact, for GIM the number of citations by published papers presented a 3.7-fold decrease and was a 3.9-fold decrease for the BMB category.
General and Internal Medicine (GIM) | |||
---|---|---|---|
Periods | 1956-1972 | 1974-1990 | 1991-2007 |
Total papers | 38 | 8,096 | 3,477 |
Citations/paper | 3.66 | 0.98 | 10.3 |
Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (BMB) | |||
Periods | 1956-1972 | 1974-1990 | 1991-2007 |
Total papers | 2 | 963 | 5,611 |
Citations/paper | 66.0 | 16.7 | 16.17 |
The increased numbers of papers published during the dictatorship period, especially for GIM category, could be related to the growth of neoliberal principles in Chile during the mid-1970s (Max-Neef 1995), according the expected relationship between money spent to publish and the number of published papers in paid WoS journals. Also, I claim that the low number of citations during the same period could be due to an “international sanction” (Escribà-Folch and Wright 2010) to Chilean researchers by the worldwide democratic scientific community. Moreover, it´s estimated that the universities that enroll 75.6% of the students have lost about 29% of their faculty members since the military intervention, that is approximately 5,000 people (Izquierdo 1975).
Based on the data of Table 1, I forward the hypothesis that the authoritarian and totalitarian regime keen the reputed scientific creativity and the intrinsic motivation of Chilean GIM and BMB researchers during the dictatorship period. I predict a more marked effect on Chilean social sciences and humanities scientific productivity and scientometric impact.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
To Christopher B. Anderson for the WoS´s search conducted for these three analyzed periods.
To Christopher B. Anderson for the WoS´s search conducted for these three analyzed periods.
References
- Amabile T.M.. (1998) How to kill creativity. Harvard Business Review 76: 76-87 Google Scholar
- Bautista M.A., González F., Martínez L.R., Muñoz P., Prem M.. (2024) IZA Discussion Papers, No. 16989 Google Scholar
- Bautista M.A., González F, Martínez L.R., Muñoz P., Prem M.. (2023) The intergenerational transmission of higher education: Evidence from the 1973 coup in Chile. Explorations in Economic History 90 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Bautista M.A., González F., Martínez L.R., Muñoz P., Prem M.. (2019) The geography of dictatorship and support for democracy. HiCN Working Paper 298: 45 pp. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Cordero P., Garreton M.A., Giannini H, Goic A., Izquierdo L., Latorre R., Minguell J., Ureta T., Varela F.F., Vivaldi E., et al. (1984) Scientists in Pinochet´s Chile. Nature 308: 310. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Escribà-Folch A., Wright J.. (2010) Dealing with tyranny: international sanctions and the survival of authoritarian rulers. International Studies Quarterly 54: 335-359 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Eyzaguirre C.. (1974) Chilean scientists remaining in the country are labouring under very difficult circumstances which are mainly economic. Funds for research are very limited, and it is very difficult to these people carry out experiments using modern techniques. Nature 250: 5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- González F., Muñoz P., Martínez L.R., Prem M.. (2024) Higher education and mortality: legacies of an authoritarian college contraction. Journal of the European Economic Association 22: 1762-1797 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Izquierdo L.. (1975) Letter from Chile. Nature 253: 5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2023.101540 | Google Scholar
- Lewandosky S., Kempe V., Armaos K., Hahn U., Abels C.M., Wibisono S., Louis W., Sah S., Pagel C., Jankowicz N., DiResta R., Markolin P., Schoenemann H., Hertwig R., Crull H., Mauer B., Holford D., Lopez-Lopez E., Cook J., et al. (2025) The Anti-Autocracy Handbook: A Scholars´ Guide to Navigating Democratic Backsliding : 31 pp. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15510834 | Google Scholar
- Litvak S.. (1984) Scientists in Pinochet´s Chile. Nature 306: 11. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15510834 | Google Scholar
- Max-Neef M.. (1995) Economic growth and quality of life: a threshold hypothesis. Ecological Economics 15: 115-118 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15510834 | Google Scholar
- . (2008) Psicología y Epistemología https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15510834 | Google Scholar